I am a member of the Sanibel and Captiva Association of Realtors and the Realtor Association of Greater Fort Myers and the Beaches. I have also earned my Sanibel and Captiva Island Specialist designation. If you are interested in learning more about Southwest Florida or about Real Estate in this area, please contact me at any time.
I grew up in Grosse Pointe, Michigan and moved to Ithaca, New York where I attended Cornell University, receiving my Bachelor of Arts degree in 1992. Before coming to Southwest Florida in 1999, I lived in Perth, Western Australia, Incline Village, Nevada, Paradise Island in the Bahamas, Chicago, Illinois, and Traverse City, Michigan. I have lived and worked on Sanibel since 2005.
I have been very involved at The Sanibel School as a volunteer in different capacities over the years, serving as a PTA President, heading the Seahorse Festival, and planning and implementing the landscaping for the entire campus. I served as the Chairperson for The Sanibel School’s School Advisory Council from 2009- 2018. I worked with the School District of Lee County and the City of Sanibel to design and create a new playground shared by the school and the recreation center and have coached youth soccer on the island and I served as a Board Member of the "Ding" Darling Wildlife Society.
Sanibel is an amazing place. It has all of the amenities and beauty of a resort destination. At the same time, it has the benefits of a small- town community. Miles of bike paths, spectacular beaches, great restaurants and shops, abundant wildlife, and a huge amount of community activities make Sanibel an ideal place to live. I feel fortunate to call Sanibel home. If you are considering a move to Sanibel, Captiva, or Fort Myers, please contact me at any time. I would be delighted to provide you with any information that would be useful to you.
I guarantee personal, attentive service. I will work with great diligence and care to identify the best choices for you as you search for a new home or investment. When it is time to sell your property, I will work efficiently and effectively to market your property and find the right buyer. I am committed to helping you with all of your Real Estate needs.
Jen's Sales Accomplishments:
Top Listing Agent August 2025
Top Producer July 2025
Top Listing Agent April 2025
Top Producer & Top Listing Agent March 2025
2024 Top Producer
Top Producer & Top Listing Agent August 2024
Top Producer & Top Sales Agent April 2024
Top Producer & Top Sales Agent February 2024
Top Sales Agent November 2023
Top Producer October 2023
Top Producer August 2023
Top Sales Agent July 2023
Top Producer June 2023
Top Listing Agent February 2023
2022 Top Listing Agent & 2022 Top Sales Agent
Top Producer, Top Listing & Top Sales Agent September 2022
Top Producer August 2022
Top Sales Agent June 2022
Top Producer April 2022
Top Producer January 2022
Jen McSorley Earns Pfeifer Realty Group Top Producer for 2021
Top Sales Agent November 2021
Top Listing Agent October 2021
Top Sales Agent September 2021
Top Listing and Sales Agent August 2021
Top Sales Agent June 2021
Top Listing Agent April 2021
Top Listing Agent February 2021
Top Sales and Listing Agent November 2020
Top Sales Agent July 2020
Top Listing Agent April 2020
Top Sales Agent February 2020
Top Sales and Listing Agent January 2020
Top Sales Agent December 2019
Top Listing and Sales Agent November 2019
Top Sales Agent September 2019
Top Listing Agent August 2019
Top Listing Agent June 2019
Top Listing Agent March 2019
Top Sales Agent February 2019
Top Sales Agent January 2019
Top Sales Agent October 2018
Top Producing Agent August 2018
Jen's Past Sales
5802 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $1,125,000- Represented Buyer
1289 Par View Drive, Sale Price $900,000- Represented Buyer
14727 Calusa Palms Drive #204, Sale Price $385,000- Represented Buyer
2658 Coconut Drive, Sale Price $2,489,000- Represented Seller
Sanibel Arms A5, Sale Price $614,000- Represented Buyer
14521 Daffodil Drive #1505, Sale Price $290,000- Represented Buyer
Tree Tops Center D1, Sale Price $279,000- Represented Buyer
Sundial G401, Sale Price $1,274,000- Represented Seller
1202 Sand Castle Road, Sale Price $1,265,000- Represented Seller
Pelican's Roost 307, Sale Price $1,450,000- Represented Buyer
20621 Country Creek Drive #3125, Sale Price $343,000- Represented Seller
Sundial B206, Sale Price $1,300,000- Represented Seller
6471 Pine Avenue, Sale Price $935,000- Represented Buyer
1560 Royal Poinciana Drive, Sale Price $1,475,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
7920 Twin Eagle Lane, Sale Price $655,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 323, Sale Price $214,180- Represented Seller
Davis Lake 215, Sale Price $191,000- Represented Buyer
Pelican's Roost 202, Sale Price $1,310,000- Represented Buyer
2444 Harbour Lane, Sale Price $2,711,000- Represented Seller
1437 Causey Court, Sale Price $1,365,000- Represented Buyer
930 Kings Crown Drive, Sale Price $1,850,000- Represented Buyer
14813 Laguna Drive, PH 1B, Sale Price $1,150,000- Represented Buyer
Mariner Pointe 251, Sale Price $900,000- Represented Seller
14531 Abaco Lake Drive #206, Sale Price $310,000- Represented Buyer
11969 Seabreeze Cove Lane, Sale Price $421,000- Represented Buyer
11921 Seabreeze Cove #106, Sale Price $294,300- Represented Seller and Buyer
3072 Coquina Drive, Sale Price $850,000- Represented Buyer
543 Boulder Drive, Sale Price $1,265,000- Represented Buyer
Marina Villa 706, Sale Price $950,000- Represented Buyer
Blind Pass A202, Sale Price $610,000- Represented Buyer
5850 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $450,000- Represented Seller
Casa Bella 104, Sale Price $140,000- Represented Buyer
5775 Baltusrol Court #301, Sale Price $656,000- Represented Buyer
5298 Umbrella Pool Road, Sale Price $985,000- Represented Buyer
16645 Crownsbury Way, Sale Price $920,000- Represented Seller
Sundial L402, Sale Price $1,389,000- Represented Buyers
18311 Mossy Glen Court, Sale Price $1,365,000- Represented Buyer
9705 Keel Court, Sale Price $410,000- Represented Seller
1512 Palm Woode Drive, Sale Price $295,000- Represented Seller
5880 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $1,310,000- Represented Seller
5786 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $1,000,000- Represented Seller
Captains Walk B5, Sale Price $390,000- Represented Buyer
4760 Rue Helene, Sale Price $1,350,000- Represented Seller
6300 South Pointe Boulevard #466, Sale Price $104,000- Represented Buyer
5817 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $1,090,000- Represented Seller
2475 Tropical Way Court, Sale Price $2,340,000- Represented Buyer
14788 Calusa Palms 102, Sale Price $215,000- Represented Seller
16392 Coco Hammock Way, Sale Price $605,000- Represented Buyer
Sanibel Siesta 801, Sale Price $725,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Woods 624, Sale Price $154,000- Represented Seller
1376 Jamaica Drive, Sale Price $750,000- Represented Seller
2857 Wulfert Road, Sale Price $1,780,000- Represented Buyer
Sandalfoot 3C1, Sale Price $630,000- Represented Buyer
Ocean's Reach 3A2, Sale Price $935,000- Represented Seller
539 Sea Oats Drive, Sale Price $385,000- Represented Seller
2563 Coconut Drive, Sale Price $1,049,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
5423 Shearwater Drive, Sale Price $1,315,000- Represented Buyer
5403 Shearwater Drive, Sale Price $1,599,000- Represented Buyer
813 Angel Wing Drive, Sale Price $2,639,000- Represented Buyer
1560 Royal Poinciana Drive, Sale Price $825,000- Represented Buyer
613 Lake Murex Circle, Sale Price $985,000- Represented Buyer
2015 Wild Lime Drive, Sale Price $560,000- Represented Buyer
976 Greenwood Court, Sale Price $515,000- Represented Seller
2479 Harbour Lane, Sale Price $1,695,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Sanibel Moorings 1512, Sale Price $529,000- Represented Buyer
1985 Sanibel Bayous Road, Sale Price $791,000- Represented Buyer
Blind Pass E207, Sale Price $466,000- Represented Buyer
9211 Dimmick Drive, Sale Price $699,000- Represented Seller
5749 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $607,000- Represented Buyer
3019 Poinciana Circle, Sale Price $1,180,718- Represented Seller
1672 Hibiscus Drive, Sale Price $889,000- Represented Buyer
13488 Villa di Preserve, Sale Price $452,500- Represented Buyer
8869 Spring Mountain Way, Sale Price $248,000- Represented Buyer
20621 Country Creek Drive #3125, Sale Price $182,000- Represented Buyer
13355 Broadhurst Loop, Sale Price $140,000- Represented Seller
Junonia 103, Sale Price $1,265,000- Represented Buyer
4067 West Gulf Drive, Sale Price $5,550,000- Represented Buyer
16727 Pheasant Court, Sale Price $221,000- Represented Buyer
280 Southwinds Drive, Sale Price $618,000- Represented Buyer
Ventura Captiva 2B, Sale Price $970,000- Represented Seller
16801 Captiva Drive, Sale Price $2,049,000- Represented Seller
8302 Charter Club Circle #5, Sale Price $167,000- Represented Buyer
3926 Coquina Drive, Sale Price $755,000- Represented Buyer
Blind Pass B111, Sale Price $420,000- Represented Seller
Sandpebble 2B, Sale Price $457,000- Represented Seller
Davis Court 222, Sale Price $147,000- Represented Seller
9248 Dimmick Drive, Sale Price $675,000- Represented Seller
23022 Crookedwood Loop, Sale Price $58,900- Represented Buyer
Davis Court 225, Sale Price $147,000- Represented Seller
915 Main Street, Sale Price $450,000- Represented Buyer
Pointe Royale #1301, Sale Price $300,000- Represented Buyer
15960 Cindy Court, Sale Price $625,000- Represented Buyer
15747 Caloosa Creek Circle, Sale Price $500,000- Represented Buyer
5304 Umbrella Pool Drive, Sale Price $750,000- Represented Seller
8898 Dartmoor Way, Sale Price- $460,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 511, Sale Price $152,000- Represented Seller
15922 Cutters Court, Sale Price $380,000- Represented Seller
301 McGregor Park Circle, Sale Price $195,000- Represented Seller
5834 Pine Tree Drive, Sale Price $675,000- Represented Buyers
2460 Harbour Lane, Sale Price $1,750,000- Represented Seller
Seawind A107, Sale Price $500,000- Represented Buyer
Harbor Place Vista 101, Sale Price $252,000- Represented Buyer
Beach Villa 2227, Sale Price $510,000- Represented Buyer
3867 McGregor Boulevard, Sale Price $434,900- Represented Buyer
Davis Woods 216, Sale Price $132,500- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 622, Sale Price $150,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Sandpebble 2F, Sale Price $425,000- Represented Seller
15178 Parkside Drive 203- Sale Price $139,000- Represented Seller
9740 Mainsail Court, Sale Price $515,000- Represented Buyer
911 South Yachtsman Drive, Sale Price $1,130,000- Represented Buyer
4619 Brainard Bayou, Sale Price $552,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 421, Sale Price $150,000- Represented Seller
5672 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $682,000- Represented Seller
Davis Woods 616, Sale Price $135,000- Represented Seller
Loggerhead Cay 134, Sale Price $960,000- Represented Seller
6447 Pine Avenue, Sale Price $552,500- Represented Seller
Ventura Captiva 2B, Sale Price $875,000- Represented Seller
Beach Home 11, Sale Price $2,285,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 614, Sale Price $151,000- Represented Seller
16801 Captiva Drive, Sale Price $1,800,000- Represented Buyer
Beach Villa 2332, Sale Price $745,000- Represented Buyer
Cottage Colony West 117, Sale Price $605,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Woods 624, Sale Price $122,500- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Woods 316, Sale Price $134,000- Represented Seller
5869 Pine Tree Drive, Sale Price $589,000- Represented Seller
974 Sand Castle, Sale Price $485,000- Represented Seller
Davis Lake 615, Sale Price $146,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
1417 Tredegar Drive, Sale Price $350,000- Represented Seller
Davis Lake 1021, Sale Price $149,999- Represented Seller and Buyer
9248 Kincaid Court, Sale Price $350,000- Represented Buyer
5306 Umbrella Pool Road, Sale Price $710,000- Represented Seller
976 Greenwood Court, Sale Price $449,000- Represented Buyer
401 Bella Vista Way, Sale Price $2,500,000- Represented Buyer
9248 Dimmick Drive, Sale Price $580,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Pine Cove 204, Sale Price $1,500,000- Represented Seller
2251 Starfish Lane, Sale Price $1,375,000- Represented Buyer
4760 Rue Helene, Sale Price $750,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Woods 712, Sale Price $130,250- Represented Seller
2640 Coconut Drive, Sale Price $1,190,500- Represented Seller and Buyer
Tennisplace C23, Sale Price $305,000- Represented Buyer
595 Piedmont Road, Sale Price $190,000- Represented Seller
Blind Pass #G201, Sale Price $468,000- Represented Seller
1435 Alhambra Drive, Sale Price $195,000- Represented Buyer
4542 Bowen Bayou, Sale Price $410,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
8740 South Lake Circle, Sale Price $330,000- Represented Buyer
9211 Dimmick Drive, Sale Price $553,000- Represented Buyer
Quail Run Condominium 13A, Sale Price $145,000- Respresented Seller and Buyer
11660 Pointe Circle Drive, Sale Price $160,000- Represented Seller
Marina Villa 803, Sale Price $715,000- Represented Buyer
4772 Tradewinds Drive, Sale Price $795,000- Represented Seller
Sandpiper Beach 506, Sale Price $670,000- Represented Buyer
16061 Waterleaf Lane, Sale Price $623,500- Represented Seller
Kelly Greens Terrace 517, Sale Price $137,000- Represented Buyer
Shorewood 3C, Sale Price $925,000- Represented Seller
Sandalfoot 3C1, Sale Price $675,000- Represented Seller
2401 Blue Crab Court, Sale Price $575,000- Represented Buyer
5690 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $875,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Lake 822, Sale Price $148,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Sunset Captiva 9, Sale Price $1,140,000- Represented Buyer
Tanglewood 1A, Sale Price $1,045,000- Represented Buyer
2548 Wulfert Road, Sale Price $640,000- Represeted Buyer
5280 Umbrella Pool Road, Sale Price $640,000- Represented Buyer
Sundial F306, Sale Price $450,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 912, Sale Price $156,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Lake 622, Sale Price $155,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Loggerhead Cay 134, Sale Price $935,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Woods 414, Sale Price $130,000- Represented Seller
Blind Pass D101, Sale Price $415,000- Represented Buyer
1613 Sand Castle Road, Sale Price $499,000- Represented Seller
9701 Keel Court, Sale Price $365,000- Represented Buyer
2626 Coconut Drive, Sale Price $329,000- Represented Buyer
14465 Cypress Trace Court, Sale Price $155,000- Represented Seller
Sanibel Sea Pines E, Sale Price $430,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
15922 Cutters Court, Sale Price $350,000- Represented Buyer
4775 Rue Helene, Sale Price $737,500- Represented Seller
Bellamar at Beachwalk 1025, Sale Price $130,000- Represented Seller
2628 Coconut Drive, Sale Price $1,224,500- Represented Buyer
6159 Starling Way, Sale Price $610,000- Represented Buyer
McGregor Park Condo #301, Sale Price $165,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Court 315, Sale Price $148,500- Represented Seller
Colonial Country Club #2405, Sale Price $147,500- Represented Buyer
Sanibel View #304, Sale Price $310,000- Represented Buyer
1573 Sautern Drive, Sale Price $320,000- Represented Seller
Blind Pass F210, Sale Price $444,000- Represented Buyer
Victoria Waterfront #202, Sale Price $202,000- Represented Buyer
5834 Bay Point Road, Sale Price $114,999- Represented Seller and Buyer
9705 Keel Court, Sale Price $359,750- Represented Buyer
Shorewood of Sanibel 2D, Sale Price $972,500- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 821, Sale Price $158,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
13355 Broadhurst Loop, Sale Price $108,900- Represented Buyer
Heritage Pointe 123, Sale Price $184,900- Represented Buyer
3152 Twin Lakes Lane, Sale Price $635,000- Represented Buyer
Mariposa 102 at Gulf Harbour, Sale Price $290,750- Represented Buyer
0 Island Inn Road, Sale Price $182,000- Represented Buyer
Kelly Greens Veranda 207, Sale Price $230,000- Represented Buyer
Kelly Greens Manor 2837, Sale Price $140,000- Represented Seller
Davis Court 221, Sale Price $146,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Pine Cove 104, Sale Price $1,270,000- Represented Buyer
Kelly Greens 286, Sale Price $215,000- Represented Seller
Davis Lake 525, Sale Price $135,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
671 Rabbit Road, Sale Price $620,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Lake 625, Sale Price $133,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Central Park South 102, Sale Price $109,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Sundial F103, Sale Price $452,450- Represented Buyer
Charter Club Circle 3, Sale Price $110,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 211, Sale Price $159,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
1511 Angel Drive, Sale Price $1,250,000- Represented Seller
3019 Poinciana Circle, Sale Price $890,000- Represented Buyer
Land's End Village 1639, Sale Price $1,350,000- Represented Buyer
Fisherman's Cove 302, Sale Price $192,250- Represented Buyer
Davis Woods 723, Sale Price $125,000- Represented Seller
Cardinal Cove A3, Sale Price $126,000- Represented Buyer
12170 Kelly Sands Way #726, Sale Price $125,000- Represented Seller
9813 Quinta Artesa Way 104, Sale Price $153,000- Represented Buyer
Sandalfoot 5A1, Sale Price $752,500- Represented Seller
Davis Woods 712, Sale Price $90,000- Represented Seller
Davis Lake 122, Sale Price $126,500- Represented Buyer
9694 Galley Court, Sale Price $375,000- Represented Seller
Davis Woods 514, Sale Price $114,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Woods 421, Sale Price $85,000- Represented Seller
Dinkins Lake Road, Vacant Land, Sale Price $215,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 511, Sale Price $125,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 622, Sale Price $125,000- Represented Buyer
16645 Crownsbury Way, Sale Price $630,000- Represented Buyer
South Pointe Villas #465, Sale Price $90,000- Represented Buyer
Mariner Pointe 951, Sale Price $410,000- Represented Buyer
Flamingo Village Homes II, Unit 5, Sale Price $115,000- Represented Seller
1456 Whiskey Creek Drive, Sale Price $249,787- Represented Buyer
Quail Run 13B, Sale Price $145,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Sundial B206, Sale Price $546,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake 221, Sale Price $124,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Court 225, Sale Price $121,350- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Woods 414, Sale Price $110,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
1573 Sautern, Sale Price $185,000- Represented Buyer
Spanish Cay A7, Sale Price $230,000- Represented Buyer
1336 Eagle Run, Sale Price $250,000- Represented Buyer
238 Southwinds Drive, Sale Price $570,000- Represented Buyer
4458 Water's Edge, Sale Price $814,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Court #223, Sale Price $115,000, Represented Seller and Buyer
1613 Sand Castle, Sale Price $455,000- Represented Buyer
Davis Lake #521, Sale Price $121,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Woods #813, Sale Price $126,000- Represented Buyer
Casa Bella #202, Sale Price $105,000- Represented Buyer
South Seas Bayside Villa #5230, Sale Price $280,500- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Lake #1014, Sale Price $118,000- Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Lake #624, Sale Price $120,000, Represented Seller
475 Sea Oats, Sale Price $715,000, Represented Buyer
Davis Lake #623, Sale Price $121,500, Represented Seller
Davis Lake #122, Sale Price $117,500, Represented Seller
Kelly Greens #609, Sale Price $133,000, Represented Seller
Davis Court #222, Sale Price $112,500, Represented Seller and Buyer
5795 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sale Price $990,000, Represented Seller
Davis Court #322, Sale Price $109,900, Represented Seller
Davis Lake #824, Sale Price $118,000, Represented Seller and Buyer
Davis Woods #513, Sale Price $102,500, Represented Seller
Davis Lake #225, Sale Price $125,000, Represented Seller
Davis Lake #912, Sale Price $118,000, Represented Seller and Buyer
Kelly Greens #286, Sale Price $155,000, Represented Buyer
Seabreeze Cove #102, Sale Price $128,000, Represented Buyer
Davis Lake #621, Sale Price $118,000, Represented Seller
Ocean's Reach #4C2, Sale Price $779,000, Represented Buyer
Davis Court #315, Sale Price $100,000, Represented Buyer
Cinnamon Cove, 11060 Caravel Circle #204, Sale Price $127,000, Represented Buyer
Davis Lake #1015, Sale Price $117,055, Represented Seller and Buyer
Quail Run #B4, Sale Price $115,000, Represented Buyer
707 Cardium, Sale Price $552,000, Represented Buyer
Blanquilla Court #5, Sale Price $96,500, Represented Buyer
Bayside Villa #5236, Sale Price $307,000, Represented Seller and Buyer